All 3 Uses

dispute
in
The Crucible
(Edited)

He was called upon to arbitrate disputes as though he were an unofficial judge, and Rebecca also enjoyed the high opinion most people had for him.
p. 25.8 *

disputes = disagreements

editor's notes: To arbitrate is to act as an impartial referee who helps people who disagree to reach an agreement.
ELIZABETH: I cannot dispute with you, sir; I lack learning for it.
p. 132.7 *

dispute = argue
DANFORTH, going to her: Goody Proctor, you are not summoned here for disputation.
p. 132.8

disputation = argument

Definitions:

(1) (dispute as in: their border dispute)
disagreement, argument, or conflict
(2) (dispute as in: She disputes his claim.)
challenge, argue about, or fight over
(3) (meaning too rare to warrant focus)